[ { "case": "special_relativity", "label": "Special relativity", "target": "special_relativity", "pivot_year": 1902, "target_d_i": 7.6115368965175465, "target_d_p": -0.35576070681690136, "target_max_abs_d": 7.6115368965175465, "target_l2": 7.619846429394941, "target_p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "rank_max_abs_d": 1, "rank_l2": 1, "rank_p_2d": 1, "per_concept": [ { "concept": "aether_optics", "d_i": -0.7767686119286749, "d_p": -0.5979439960558776, "max_abs_d": 0.7767686119286749, "l2": 0.9802583837422008, "p_2d": 0.09958008398320337, "n_exceed": 497, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "electrodynamics", "d_i": -0.7764372297227451, "d_p": -0.1466131327769054, "max_abs_d": 0.7764372297227451, "l2": 0.7901583274269717, "p_2d": 0.1241751649670066, "n_exceed": 620, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "electron_theory", "d_i": 0.7053428961778774, "d_p": 0.14760477639390002, "max_abs_d": 0.7053428961778774, "l2": 0.7206217948430987, "p_2d": 0.645870825834833, "n_exceed": 3229, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "gravitation", "d_i": 0.0, "d_p": 0.0, "max_abs_d": 0.0, "l2": 0.0, "p_2d": 1.0, "n_exceed": -1, "n_null": 0 }, { "concept": "instrumentation_measurement", "d_i": 0.0, "d_p": 0.0, "max_abs_d": 0.0, "l2": 0.0, "p_2d": 1.0, "n_exceed": -1, "n_null": 0 }, { "concept": "mechanics_time_measurement", "d_i": 0.0, "d_p": 0.0, "max_abs_d": 0.0, "l2": 0.0, "p_2d": 1.0, "n_exceed": -1, "n_null": 0 }, { "concept": "radiation_quantum", "d_i": 0.0, "d_p": 0.0, "max_abs_d": 0.0, "l2": 0.0, "p_2d": 1.0, "n_exceed": -1, "n_null": 0 }, { "concept": "special_relativity", "d_i": 7.6115368965175465, "d_p": -0.35576070681690136, "max_abs_d": 7.6115368965175465, "l2": 7.619846429394941, "p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "n_exceed": 0, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "spectroscopy", "d_i": 1.2628699089660684, "d_p": 0.8235162891435326, "max_abs_d": 1.2628699089660684, "l2": 1.5076536357720562, "p_2d": 0.07258548290341932, "n_exceed": 362, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "thermodynamics_kinetic_theory", "d_i": -0.6748666620482091, "d_p": -0.48552726574871546, "max_abs_d": 0.6748666620482091, "l2": 0.8313734042712189, "p_2d": 0.710257948410318, "n_exceed": 3551, "n_null": 5000 } ] }, { "case": "higgs", "label": "Higgs mechanism", "target": "higgs_mechanism", "pivot_year": 1959, "target_d_i": -3.2530731371947845, "target_d_p": -14.568841911471571, "target_max_abs_d": 14.568841911471571, "target_l2": 14.927613321539011, "target_p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "rank_max_abs_d": 1, "rank_l2": 1, "rank_p_2d": 1, "per_concept": [ { "concept": "higgs_mechanism", "d_i": -3.2530731371947845, "d_p": -14.568841911471571, "max_abs_d": 14.568841911471571, "l2": 14.927613321539011, "p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "n_exceed": 0, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "gauge_theories", "d_i": 2.1445210506084877, "d_p": 0.5273160599043761, "max_abs_d": 2.1445210506084877, "l2": 2.2084004988986954, "p_2d": 0.013797240551889621, "n_exceed": 68, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "weak_interactions", "d_i": -2.396868249921874, "d_p": 2.5003634473509604, "max_abs_d": 2.5003634473509604, "l2": 3.463638950054166, "p_2d": 0.33573285342931414, "n_exceed": 1678, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "qed_radiative", "d_i": -0.21919016734154595, "d_p": 3.0305480659231545, "max_abs_d": 3.0305480659231545, "l2": 3.0384643998786274, "p_2d": 0.030393921215756847, "n_exceed": 151, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "s_matrix_bootstrap", "d_i": 2.2900460419271, "d_p": -0.9644031462133794, "max_abs_d": 2.2900460419271, "l2": 2.4848308398303978, "p_2d": 0.001799640071985603, "n_exceed": 8, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "current_algebra", "d_i": 1.344805149602398, "d_p": 0.44383288185590436, "max_abs_d": 1.344805149602398, "l2": 1.4161527168401173, "p_2d": 0.10577884423115377, "n_exceed": 528, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "quark_model", "d_i": 2.909675314632413, "d_p": 1.2615879089533972, "max_abs_d": 2.909675314632413, "l2": 3.171405759059953, "p_2d": 0.035992801439712056, "n_exceed": 179, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "strong_interactions", "d_i": -1.126339549448339, "d_p": 3.4405059374107334, "max_abs_d": 3.4405059374107334, "l2": 3.6201825763364472, "p_2d": 0.03499300139972006, "n_exceed": 174, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "electroweak_unification", "d_i": 0.9641783295839462, "d_p": -0.05959819096860664, "max_abs_d": 0.9641783295839462, "l2": 0.9660185275687104, "p_2d": 0.036392721455708855, "n_exceed": 181, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "renormalizability", "d_i": 1.3291488207945463, "d_p": 0.7276580027477634, "max_abs_d": 1.3291488207945463, "l2": 1.515296260400057, "p_2d": 0.07158568286342731, "n_exceed": 357, "n_null": 5000 } ] }, { "case": "godel", "label": "Godel incompleteness", "target": "incompleteness", "pivot_year": 1937, "target_d_i": 0.4959255785702684, "target_d_p": 2.4955344782426976, "target_max_abs_d": 2.4955344782426976, "target_l2": 2.544333805061417, "target_p_2d": 0.0003999200159968006, "rank_max_abs_d": 1, "rank_l2": 1, "rank_p_2d": 1, "per_concept": [ { "concept": "incompleteness", "d_i": 0.4959255785702684, "d_p": 2.4955344782426976, "max_abs_d": 2.4955344782426976, "l2": 2.544333805061417, "p_2d": 0.0003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 1, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "hilbert_program", "d_i": 0.0, "d_p": 0.0, "max_abs_d": 0.0, "l2": 0.0, "p_2d": 1.0, "n_exceed": -1, "n_null": 0 }, { "concept": "axiomatic_set_theory", "d_i": 0.5645796718411505, "d_p": -0.43835066382740195, "max_abs_d": 0.5645796718411505, "l2": 0.7147737476531894, "p_2d": 0.7000599880023995, "n_exceed": 3500, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "type_theory", "d_i": -1.4306910659424392, "d_p": -0.929681665746676, "max_abs_d": 1.4306910659424392, "l2": 1.7062194834759763, "p_2d": 0.0003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 1, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "intuitionism", "d_i": 1.8826379753553446, "d_p": 0.19057493555873647, "max_abs_d": 1.8826379753553446, "l2": 1.8922591134179503, "p_2d": 0.02559488102379524, "n_exceed": 127, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "computability", "d_i": 0.9235934536530342, "d_p": 0.6148637280322412, "max_abs_d": 0.9235934536530342, "l2": 1.1095414691125545, "p_2d": 0.3153369326134773, "n_exceed": 1576, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "model_theory", "d_i": 0.7952844683986812, "d_p": -0.44420770367583273, "max_abs_d": 0.7952844683986812, "l2": 0.9109324177353276, "p_2d": 0.14357128574285144, "n_exceed": 717, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "proof_theory", "d_i": 1.6135987695720553, "d_p": 0.5114617432786687, "max_abs_d": 1.6135987695720553, "l2": 1.6927179635137406, "p_2d": 0.05138972205558888, "n_exceed": 256, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "algebraic_logic", "d_i": 1.1162176962915875, "d_p": -0.13206112716640225, "max_abs_d": 1.1162176962915875, "l2": 1.1240027076581975, "p_2d": 0.36732653469306137, "n_exceed": 1836, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "propositional_calculus", "d_i": 1.8257826385913243, "d_p": -0.48148300316886955, "max_abs_d": 1.8257826385913243, "l2": 1.8882023529595582, "p_2d": 0.029394121175764846, "n_exceed": 146, "n_null": 5000 } ] }, { "case": "deep_learning", "label": "Deep learning", "target": "deep_learning", "pivot_year": 2011, "target_d_i": -1.5457856873857563, "target_d_p": -3.1268157458948687, "target_max_abs_d": 3.1268157458948687, "target_l2": 3.488041011814904, "target_p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "rank_max_abs_d": 1, "rank_l2": 2, "rank_p_2d": 1, "per_concept": [ { "concept": "deep_learning", "d_i": -1.5457856873857563, "d_p": -3.1268157458948687, "max_abs_d": 3.1268157458948687, "l2": 3.488041011814904, "p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "n_exceed": 0, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "kernel_methods", "d_i": -2.3576809419897446, "d_p": 2.168237986974584, "max_abs_d": 2.3576809419897446, "l2": 3.203110268532953, "p_2d": 0.003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 19, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "graphical_models", "d_i": -2.892323797128605, "d_p": 2.0473698278372368, "max_abs_d": 2.892323797128605, "l2": 3.5436224628725204, "p_2d": 0.0003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 1, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "ensemble_methods", "d_i": -1.7152640368276435, "d_p": 0.024161034750408268, "max_abs_d": 1.7152640368276435, "l2": 1.715434193326714, "p_2d": 0.2471505698860228, "n_exceed": 1235, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "dimensionality_reduction", "d_i": -1.2752432243223806, "d_p": -0.36727560339166615, "max_abs_d": 1.2752432243223806, "l2": 1.3270782380955743, "p_2d": 0.11897620475904819, "n_exceed": 594, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "reinforcement_learning", "d_i": -2.0704263115599235, "d_p": 2.007040193288758, "max_abs_d": 2.0704263115599235, "l2": 2.8835525743561887, "p_2d": 0.022195560887822437, "n_exceed": 110, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "feature_engineering", "d_i": -1.8970500805193407, "d_p": -1.476528634534168, "max_abs_d": 1.8970500805193407, "l2": 2.4039417248755783, "p_2d": 0.5578884223155369, "n_exceed": 2789, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "convex_optimization", "d_i": -1.5300860639186316, "d_p": 2.8911639889117327, "max_abs_d": 2.8911639889117327, "l2": 3.2710843116278756, "p_2d": 0.0613877224555089, "n_exceed": 306, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "nlp_pretransformer", "d_i": -2.136389905753697, "d_p": 2.107660376744247, "max_abs_d": 2.136389905753697, "l2": 3.001065492971453, "p_2d": 0.003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 19, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "generative_models", "d_i": -0.7211317767648521, "d_p": -1.1318086661364188, "max_abs_d": 1.1318086661364188, "l2": 1.3420215706915937, "p_2d": 0.0001999600079984003, "n_exceed": 0, "n_null": 5000 } ] }, { "case": "attention", "label": "Attention mechanism", "target": "attention_mechanism", "pivot_year": 2012, "target_d_i": 1.6401377647515951, "target_d_p": 0.8986035654307184, "target_max_abs_d": 1.6401377647515951, "target_l2": 1.8701711833864723, "target_p_2d": 0.015796840631873626, "rank_max_abs_d": 4, "rank_l2": 4, "rank_p_2d": 3, "per_concept": [ { "concept": "attention_mechanism", "d_i": 1.6401377647515951, "d_p": 0.8986035654307184, "max_abs_d": 1.6401377647515951, "l2": 1.8701711833864723, "p_2d": 0.015796840631873626, "n_exceed": 78, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "recurrent_networks", "d_i": 0.5585374057223307, "d_p": -0.9104509750080291, "max_abs_d": 0.9104509750080291, "l2": 1.0681221893978714, "p_2d": 0.029994001199760048, "n_exceed": 149, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "convolutional_networks", "d_i": -2.411208007171017, "d_p": -2.5218986435241, "max_abs_d": 2.5218986435241, "l2": 3.4891111793771095, "p_2d": 0.0003999200159968006, "n_exceed": 1, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "word_embeddings", "d_i": -3.2196811965767105, "d_p": 1.1133286189009344, "max_abs_d": 3.2196811965767105, "l2": 3.4067356253829706, "p_2d": 0.1261747650469906, "n_exceed": 630, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "pretraining_finetuning", "d_i": -0.6557382287229175, "d_p": -1.0991554824143612, "max_abs_d": 1.0991554824143612, "l2": 1.279896636111767, "p_2d": 0.02519496100779844, "n_exceed": 125, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "reinforcement_learning", "d_i": -2.2530588352587184, "d_p": 3.55925002460183, "max_abs_d": 3.55925002460183, "l2": 4.212426243005983, "p_2d": 0.0015996800639872025, "n_exceed": 7, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "generative_models", "d_i": 0.8672964031410763, "d_p": 0.09815350098274203, "max_abs_d": 0.8672964031410763, "l2": 0.8728328366053935, "p_2d": 0.02459508098380324, "n_exceed": 122, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "optimization_methods", "d_i": -0.5739325775161004, "d_p": -0.09591229030192862, "max_abs_d": 0.5739325775161004, "l2": 0.5818915457069608, "p_2d": 0.13637272545490903, "n_exceed": 681, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "graph_networks", "d_i": 1.5445525119643144, "d_p": -0.14724820835284796, "max_abs_d": 1.5445525119643144, "l2": 1.5515555088614772, "p_2d": 0.017196560687862426, "n_exceed": 85, "n_null": 5000 }, { "concept": "representation_learning", "d_i": -1.0128919871080337, "d_p": 1.1264684256439086, "max_abs_d": 1.1264684256439086, "l2": 1.5148865606111657, "p_2d": 0.05018996200759848, "n_exceed": 250, "n_null": 5000 } ] } ]